What are Difference between the thin shell, thick shell, membrane element and Layered. Uses and applications. Why?

What are Difference between the thin shell, thick shell, membrane element and Layered. Uses and applications. Why?

Thin Shell Element 

  1. Inplane & Out of plane stiffness shall be calculated by the program by performing analysis. 
  2. Finite element meshing is compulsory for modeling such type of element

Applications

  1. Normal RC Beam and slab structures.
  2. Irregular slabs, PT slabs, Flat slabs, shear walls


Thick Shell Element:
  1. In plane and out of plane stiffness along with shear deformation shall be calculated by the program while performing analysis.
  2. Finite element meshing is compulsory for such modeling type of element
  3. The thick plate formulation is recommended to use when the shear deformations become significant. The thick plate formulation captures both shear and bending deformations, whereas the thin plate the formulation is based only on bending deformations and neglects shear deformations.

Applications

  1. Raft slabs, foundation pads, transfer slab
  2. Column capital in case of flat slab


Membrane Element:
  1. Only in-plane stiffness shall be considered by the program while performing analysis.
  2. Finite Element Meshing must be avoided.
  3. Which is applied to membrane objects transfers directly to supporting structural objects, whereas meshed shell objects have bending stiffness and therefore resist a portion of the load through flexural deformation. As a result, less load will be available to transfer to beams located under a shell, while 100% of the load will transfer through a membrane.

Applications

  1. Staircase slab, Precast slabs
  2. Ramp slabs, deck slab, profile slab, etc
  3. Yield line theory shall be considered by the program while performing analysis.

Layered  

  1. Within layered shell objects, straight normal remain straight, which enforces full composite the behavior between layers.
  2. For membrane and bending behavior, quadratic displacement fields are assumed, with appropriate handling to prevent shear locking Plane- stress behavior is assumed within each layer.
  3. Straight normal do not necessarily remain normal to the mid-surface, which allows transverse shear deformation.



    • Related Articles

    • What is the Meshing in Finite Element Method?

      A mesh is a network of line elements and interconnecting nodes used to model a structural system and numerically solve for its simulated behavior under applied loading. First, computational techniques create an analytical model by populating the ...
    • What are the types and uses of the Diaphragm?

      Diaphragm are the mathematical operator which transfers the lateral forces to the vertical elements. Diaphragm are of two types. Rigid Diaphragm and Semi-Rigid Diaphragm. Rigid Diaphragm Software will consider the infinite stiffness in its own plane. ...
    • What is the difference between Time History and Response Spectrum?

      Time History  This method calculates the response of a structure subjected to earthquake excitation at every instant of time (hence the name Time History). Various seismic data are necessary to carry out the seismic analysis i.e. acceleration, ...
    • What are shoring piles?

      Shoring is used to support a structure to prevent a collapse. The most common shoring techniques that we encountered are during the early stage of construction which is an excavation. Shoring is intended to support a deep excavation to prevent the ...
    • What is stiffness modifiers?

      Shell or area element has two types of stiffnesses i.e. in-plane stiffness refers to f11, f22 and f12 and out-of-plane stiffness refers to m11, m22 and m12. Refer to the below Figure which shows the direction of local axes and their corresponding ...